The Governance Library curated by Matthew Doyle
Strategy Room · Note 12
ESG Framework
00:00 / 11:00
mæd partners
Scene 1
Hero
H1: ESG.
Sub: Three letters that have carried a larger argument than any of them can bear. Not a belief system. A measurement language.
Scene 2
Frame
Eyebrow: `STRATEGY ROOM · NOTE 12 OF 15`
H1: ESG Framework.
Scene 3
Origin
Date plate: 2004.
Caption: UN Global Compact · "Who Cares Wins".
Date plate: 2006.
Caption: Principles for Responsible Investment launched.
Pull stat: PRI signatories · ~$120tn AUM by 2024.
Scene 4
The framework landscape (Path-2)
Eyebrow: `THE INSTRUMENT IS NOT ONE FRAMEWORK · IT IS MANY`
Two columns.
- Rating providers: MSCI · Sustainalytics · ISS ESG · Refinitiv.
- Reporting standards: GRI · SASB · TCFD · ISSB S-1 / S-2 · CSRD · UK SDR · SEC climate rule.
Scene 5
The point of the letters
ESG does not prescribe.
It gives a shared language.
Disagreement about values, conducted in shared variables.
Scene 6
Argument card
ESG is a vocabulary, not a policy.
Used well: rating divergence is information.
Used badly: highest rating becomes "the truth".
Scene 7
Case anchor
H1: BP plc.
Sub: Strategic Reset · February 2025.
Scene 8
Pre-reset scorecard
Eyebrow: `BP SCORECARD · 2020 TO 2024`
Eight rows:
Scope-1, scope-2, scope-3 emissions.
Transition capex as % of total capex.
Renewables operating capacity (GW).
Methane intensity.
Safety metrics (Deepwater Horizon).
Water intensity.
Board diversity.
Executive pay equity.
Scene 9
Post-reset scorecard
Eyebrow: `WHAT MOVED · WHAT STAYED`
Two columns.
- Removed / reduced: 40% oil cut · transition capex commitment · renewables capacity goal.
- Retained: Methane intensity · Safety · Water · Board diversity.
Scene 10
The ratings response (Path-2)
Three rows under date plate `MARCH 2025`.
MSCI · AA → A.
Sustainalytics · Risk medium → high.
ISS ESG · climate-leadership classification withdrawn.
Scene 11
The critique
Caption: Bebchuk & Tallarita, Vanderbilt Law Review, 2022.
Pulled fragment: "The ESG apparatus is less a measurement system than a legitimation system."
Counter, in teal: Sometimes. Not always.
Scene 12
Positive contrast
H1: Schneider Electric SE.
Sub: Tricoire chair · Blum CEO from 2024.
Pill: `POSITIVE CONTRAST · ESG AS DISCIPLINE`
Scene 13
Schneider ratings strip
Three-row strip:
MSCI · AAA.
Sustainalytics · low risk.
ISS ESG · decile 1.
Caption: Sustained leadership across every major provider for over a decade.
Scene 14
Schneider's discipline
Eyebrow: `WHAT SCHNEIDER DOES`
Three rows:
Six-year Schneider Sustainability Impact pipeline · refreshed quarterly.
Operational metrics in segment reporting · variance reporting.
Remuneration committee weights them in the LTIP.
Scene 15
The synthesis
Hero card.
The framework can be used as cover.
The framework can be used as discipline.
The board's choice is which use it will make.
The vocabulary's job is to make disagreement sayable.
Scene 16
Credit
Curated by Matthew Doyle · mæd partners.
---
Educational material · not legal, regulatory, or investment advice · see `00 - Disclaimers.md` for the full notice · © 2026 mæd partners limited.